AXA Ban Update and Appeal - January, 2008
Appeal of AXA’s Ban - AXA Ban Update January 22, 2008:
I have not given up. Why should I ?
I am not guilty of anything warranting this ban or any form of punishment.
FYI: I am posting
And, this link has
http://www.untouchab
Please, do the only fair thing.
Please, do the only just thing.
Please, do the only right thing. Please:
Lift the ban and return ALL of my assets and make compensation and restitution for the additional damages, now.
If my ban has not
So, instead, I ask this one last time that we take care of
Thanks
AXA’s APPEAL
The Short Form - An Open Appeal From AXA to to Jay, Rob and Dave:
I believe all of you really want to be fair and with that in mind I am asking you to please consider my appeal to you asking that you lift my ban.
Please lift my ban now and return ALL my assets to my account including ALL my Ideas and compounded interest due.
Your immediate attention is kindly requested. Thank you.
Below you will find a large document detailing some of the the problems, but, first consider these most important points:
I never should never have been removed from the game.
I should never have been linked to any ‘charges’ against PnP or banned along with PnP as if we are one player.
In fairness we are two people and two sets of charges are necessary. I am not PnP.
If my ban is examined and considered separately from PnP’s it should be easy to see that it is only right to lift my ban.
Because, in any case, I am not guilty. I am innocent.
I am not guilty of anything and my transactions records prove my innocence. The time I spent collecting ideas precludes my participation in the activities I am accused of.
Again: I should never have been removed from the game. Many players know this and would speak on my behalf and in my defense but they have been silenced by fiat and intimidation. Some have been silenced by means of being given game staff positions and are now in fear of losing those positions. A very clever yet morally bankrupt ploy which has succeeded in stacking the deck against me. In addition it appears as if AdamF may be telling many of my former game friends and other players lies about me, too.
I am the victim of either a series of errors or intentional lies or some combination of both. The results are a series of injustices which have caused me harm.
I have been falsely and wrongly accused.
I have been ‘tried’ in a ’star chamber’ and ’sentenced’ by an ‘echo chamber’ without any evidence of any guilt on my part or any opportunity to defend myself with the truth.
I wish to remedy this unfair situation and solve these problems amicably and expeditiously by means of the following actions, now:
My Permaban has always been and still is wrong and should be reversed.
My account should be immediately reactivated.
All further actions taken against me and any of my assets after the ban was imposed should immediately be reversed and all assets returned to me. This is especially true in regards to my Ideas Collection.
All of my assets including ALL of my Ideas Collection and all Assets Due* since the wrongful ban went into effect should be returned to my account.
*(Assets Due: .05% compound interest per day from my corporate investments and extension of my Premium account to compensate me for all time missed due to the ban).
All game privileges, forums access and #blogshares irc access should be reinstated.
Please lift my ban now and let’s go forward with a better understanding.
Additionally, it will be impossible to ever fully compensate me for lost time in game play.
Since I have been wronged and suffered various harms and damages from the wrongful actions I expect some additional efforts will be made to try to compensate me.
I suggest the additional compensation begins with 10001 ideas of any industry in which any artifact was released during my ban. Compensation should also include the remainder of the ideas I needed to complete the Dr. Seuss artifact. I would have finished building it within days of when the ban was imposed.
Consider these things as some additional compensation for the many hidden damages suffered by me. No matter what was intended the wrongful actions of the ban and the unwarranted and unprecedented sell off of my Ideas have caused me undue stress and harm and additional reparations are due me.
If all of these conditions are not met, then as has been made clear, I will take all necessary legal actions outside of the context of this appeal and the game in order to remedy this unjust ban situation and the harms and damages it has caused me.
Also, game staff has denied player Onyx access to the forums and to #blogshares in irc. That must end as well.
Thank you,
AXA/Charles Silver
PS: A Note on Blacklists and “The Memory Hole”:
I have always been struck by how much Blogshares presents a fairly accurate microcosm of the totalitarian/authoritarian political landscapes we all inhabit. Parallels abound. Those with the capacity may make note of the parallels and draw their own conclusions.
As many of you know in George Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-Four the ‘Memory Hole’ is an oblong slit in Winston Smith’s office at The Ministry of Truth. That is where Winston Smith dropped bits and pieces of ‘purged’ historical truth and facts which were inconvenient to the ‘Party’, i.e., TPTB. Then these inconvenient truths were vented away to a furnace and burned. For those who don’t know about or understand this I will try to explain using some quotations from the recent book Finding George Orwell in Burma by Emma Larkin:
“The writer told me about one of the most respected and prolific historians living in Burma, who had made some outspoken comments during an international radio interview. ‘We can no longer write his name in magazines or newspapers and he cannot be mentioned anymore,’ the writer said. The historian’s articles have been banned, and his books have been taken out of bookshops.”
“People disappeared like this in Nineteen Eighty-Four: ‘Your name was removed from the registers, every record of everything you had ever done was wiped out, your one-time existence was denied and then forgotten. You were abolished, annihilated: vaporized was the usual word.’ ”
I believe something similar has happened to me when I was wrongly banned from the game and later when all of my Ideas Collection were sold. These brutal actions were intended to strike at the heart and soul of their ‘target’ and intimidate any who might question them. These actions derive from the same cold calculating mindset one always finds when one more closely examines any totalitarian/authoritarian regime.
Is this type of rule really the best behavior that can be expected or requested of TPTB at Blogshares ? I for one certainly hope not.
AXA Ban Update January, 2008
Please Note: This very long post will reprise the salient points of and supercede all previous posts to date. Updates and additional edits may be posted as and if necessary. All previous posts on this topic have been removed while further actions to appeal, address and remedy the unwarranted ‘ban’ are prepared. Interested parties please check back for further updates. Thanks.
This current combined post was updated as of January 8th, 2008. Clarifications and additional commentary on the ban are included. Included below is an current edit of the “Last Post”.
The story is not yet finished, the problem is not yet solved. I am hoping that Jay in his new and additional role as Game Director and Subwolf who has always been fair in the end will work with me to resolve this issue by lifting my ban.
Being innocent of any wrongdoing I believe in the end I will be fully satisfied with the resolution whether resolved within the game or in a setting outside of the game in a manner that will fully compensate me for all harm done to me.
I still prefer the former but if forced will pursue the latter.
For those who want to know something about the origins of my ban:
First: I have not done anything wrong. This Ban is a Travesty. I should never have been banned. I am not guilty. There is no evidence against me. To carry out my ban they had to accuse me of and act as if I was working with PnP (and MNO ? and others ?).
Linking me to PnP: That is the BIG ERROR or the BIG LIE which is the foundation of my ban.
I was not working with PnP nor with MNO nor any others to attack anyone.
It is not right to treat me as if I am PnP and it is not right to ban me. I am not PnP and I am not guilty of anything.
They didn’t have evidence then, they don’t have any now.
If there were even a grain of evidence against me it would have been presented to the BSEC.
Without any evidence to support the ban this issue could not go to the BSEC.
Instead, to be rid of me they had to either act from the perspective of being misinformed or the intentionally had to LIE.
The Ban came without any warning. Without any charges. Without any BSEC involvement. Without any evidence.
I was instantly PERMABANNED and stripped of over two years of work and assets.
I could not and can not access my account and game assets, access any messages which might have been used in my defense, PM any players, join Blogshares irc, or post in the Forums. I was offered no opportunity to defend myself.
I repeat: There was no evidence, no charges, no rules violations, no warnings and no defense was permitted.
Why ? Because they had nothing on me. They had no evidence. There is no evidence that might warrant such a ban and stripping of any player’s assets.
This Ban was and is still Unprecedented, Unwarranted, Unfair.
My ban is unsupportable. It could not have occurred except by misunderstandings, misperceptions and errors or by intentional lies and deception.
For those who want to know even more about the origins of my ban:
I am posting regular
and, here, below the short
I may be a bit harsh
AdamF’s errors in fact and judgment resulted in the wrong actions he initiated against me. I believe he
In that PM he reveals his deeply rooted misunderstanding when he accuses me falsely. All of his errors in judgment resulted in his uninformed and ill advised drive to manufacture the conditions for and the implementation of the unwarranted ban which has caused me so much harm and suffering.
Without any evidence and after indulging in bizarre paranoid fantasies with her like-minded friends (which included Sage and Matrixz at the very least) Sarabear had a strangely conspiratorial discussion in a chat with AdamF.
After that chat Sarabear sent a PM of part of that exchange to a list of players to garner support for her and Sage’s and Matrixz ’s vigilante agenda. They had incorrectly decided I was somehow involved in attacks against their assets and the assets of others of their corporation mates and friends. Further, Sage seemed to also be under the false and paranoid impression that I was cheating, asserting that I have two accounts. She is absolutely incorrect about this, too. Onyx is a real person with her own account. Onyx can and will answer any questions about this.
Note: I WAS NOT involved in any way with any of these ‘attack’s and: I was not cheating, I have never cheated. There is no evidence to support any charges against me.
More than likely I am perceived as an unlikeable wise ass to some players. OK, but check this out: Being an unlikeable wise ass is not against any rules.
In any case these ‘attacks’ (by PnP or other players) if they occurred may have been obnoxious but they were all legal play under game rules.
Importantly: I was not in any way participating in any of these ‘daily’ ‘attacks’. I was too busy with other aspects of the game:
I spent ALL of my game time collecting Rare ideas, building the best Ideas collection in the history of the game (most industries with the most ideas in each industry) and collecting Artifacts. My transactions history provides absolute proof that this is the absolute truth.
I am not guilty and I should not be banned. I did nothing to deserve my being stripped of all of my ideas, either. That is especially wrong and will be dealt with below.
At the end of the chat PM AdamF, either by means of being misinformed or quite intentionally, created a false impression of my guilt with this erroneous and actionable misstatement or intentional heinous lie about my involvement when he said:
“It’s time people stopped feeling sorry for themselves, stopped fearing the reprisals in the short-term, and say what they feel and how 2 minority players are affecting the enjoyment for however many people they shit on daily.”
This is where the problem began. AdamF is WRONG. He is either very misinformed or intentionally lying. In any case AdamF is ABSOLUTELY INCORRECT. I was not guilty of his charge. There is no evidence to support AdamF’s characterization of me as one of these “2″ players.
Neither he nor anyone else can back up this claim with any evidence. Don’t take my word for it, ask for the evidence. There is no evidence that I was ’shit’ing on anyone every day or ever.
For those interested in the truth, my ideas transactions records prove AdamF is wrong and there are plenty of players familiar with the focus and style of my game play who know that AdamF is wrong. Most of them are too afraid to speak up in my defense.
Notice: AdamF (or anyone else): I Challenge you to provide any evidence which will prove your claim.
This is the conspiratorial message that sara sent out which is based on false information and which led directly to the wrongful ban:
“pnp, axa and mno
From sara bear
Block messages from this user
To XXXXXXXXXXXXX
Date 21:07 29 Oct 2007
Please read the mesage (sic) below and contact AdamF if you want to have the asshats removed from the game. It is not in their best interest for players to leave, and they need to know that the reason people are doing so is because of the asshats.
message adam here:
http://blogshares.com/yabbse/index.php?action=profile;u=13829
08:17 PM sarabear because he, mno and pnp are running off a lot of people this week (*NOTE: This is very interesting and untrue.)
08:17 PM sarabear including me
08:17 PM sarabear i’m done
08:17 PM sarabear count is up to about 8 major players
08:17 PM AdamF Then a ban will serve no purpose.
08:17 PM sarabear that i know of offhand
08:18 PM sarabear at least 5 said they would stay if MNO, pnp and AXA were gone
08:18 PM sarabear maybe 6
08:19 PM AdamF Unfortunately these 6 need to make their declarations to that fact to me or someone else. I cannot, and nor can anyone else, do anything without them doing so.
08:20 PM sarabear i don’t understand
08:20 PM sarabear honey and sage already have
08:20 PM AdamF 2.
08:20 PM AdamF 2 for 2.
08:20 PM AdamF Not a good argument.
08:20 PM sarabear and what good is any declaration?
08:20 PM sarabear i don’t understand
08:21 PM AdamF If 10.. 20 players each make it known that AXA and PnP are the primary reason for their considering of quitting, then maybe it’ll be worthy of an application for a ban on them.
08:22 PM AdamF However 2 players saying they’ll leave because of 2 other players, it’s not an economic argument worth having.
08:23 PM sarabear if any of them believed that would make a difference, i am sure they would have done it
08:23 PM * AdamF shrugs
08:23 PM AdamF nothing I can do then.
08:24 PM AdamF Sage started the ball rolling on a ban and left before she finished it. (*NOTE: This is very interesting.)
08:24 PM AdamF With a lack of supporting evidence to the contrary, they will remain.
08:24 PM sarabear my point is, it has been asked…. and they are leavong because no one has done anything
08:25 PM AdamF And MY point is, no one has told me.
08:25 PM AdamF Save you and Honey.
08:25 PM sarabear sage told you
08:25 PM AdamF No, Sage told me she was quitting, and then quit.
08:25 PM AdamF Prior to that she mentioned she’d like to ban AXA and PnP. (*NOTE: This is very interesting, too.)
08:25 PM AdamF The two were not inter-related specifically.
08:26 PM sarabear she told me that she has been begging for action for ages and left because she felt nothing was going to happen
08:26 PM AdamF Yes, well, there are 2 sides to every story.
08:27 PM AdamF The short of it is I’d sponsor a ban on both IF I thought the community would publicly back me. (*NOTE: This is very interesting as well.)
08:27 PM AdamF However, I know it won’t, so without those depositions, I will not be recommending anything.
08:27 PM sarabear the community thinks no one will back them
08:28 PM sarabear how many do you need to come to you
08:28 PM AdamF 6-10 would be a start. I can turn Sage’s retirement into another. MrPilot will back it as well. (*NOTE: This is very interesting, we see AdamF becoming invested in bringing about the ban.)
08:29 PM sarabear honey is not gone yet
08:29 PM sarabear we had planned to leave by the end of the week
08:29 PM AdamF That will be enough to bring it to Dave, who said something along the lines of “if there is enough of a case for them to be removed from the game, for the good of it, then I will do so.”
08:29 PM sarabear may i quote you
08:30 PM AdamF If you want to quote a mis-quote, then yes. lol. Those were not his exact words because I can’t remember them, but that was what his sentence meant.
08:30 PM sarabear i am not wanting to quote what you and he said, merely that the possibility is there if everyone stands up and makes their opinion known
08:31 PM AdamF I don’t want people to leave, Sara. Even if it appears I don’t care. But I am in a difficult position of having to justify every action, and every recommendation. That is an impossible position if no one will support me.
08:31 PM sarabear i kept messaging you to talk about it, but i guess you never saw my messages
08:32 PM sarabear about 3X a day for the last 2 weeks (*NOTE: This is very interesting, too.)
08:32 PM AdamF It’s time people stopped feeling sorry for themselves, stopped fearing the reprisals in the short-term, and say what they feel and how 2 minority players are affecting the enjoyment for however many people they shit on daily.” (*NOTE: This is very interesting as well as plain WRONG.)
Don’t take my word for it, ask for proof, ask for evidence:
Did I cheat to get my cash ? No. There is no evidence of that.
Did I cheat to get my ideas ? No. There is no evidence of that.
Did I cheat at all ? No. There is no evidence of that.
Did I play ‘aggressively’ ? No. There is no evidence of that.
Did I harass players ? No. There is no evidence of that.
So: Why was I removed from the game ?
And: Why were ALL my ideas sold off ?
There is no valid reason for my ban or the unprecedented sell off of ALL my ideas.
There is no reason whatsoever.
Don’t take my word for it, demand the evidence. They will not provide any evidence. They can’t.
You will not see any evidence because there is no evidence against me at all.
These are the things which demand explanation and demand remedy.
Will these things be remedied in the game or in a court of law ?
Time will tell. More soon.
And, that’s all I can say now, friends. Have FUN !
Regards, AXA, January, 8, 2008
Edit/Update: CENSORED: The Last Post by AXA Re the Game Ban
TPTB at Blogshares do not want anyone to see this post. An earlier version was removed from the forums at Blogshares.
This is typical of their patterns of abuse of power and mistreatment of selected players. It is another tool they used to cut off discussion and to intimidate players.
They want you compliant. They want you scared. They do not want you to question their actions or speak in my defense.
Here is some proof which I received this after asking a player to see if they could make a ‘last post’ for me:
“I talked to Adam at length about your goodbye post. He said he had removed one earlier that shadow had put up on your behalf. He also said that there cannot be one and that he is sorry. I don’t know what else to do. They will remove whatever I post or whoever posts on your behalf. It’s a sucky way for all of this to end.”
Yes, it certainly is and here is what I would post if I could:
It seems, so far, that a few of you have finally managed to see your wet dreams come true. You may not like me and that’s OK. I don’t like everyone here either. But, being unlikeable is not a violation of any rules.
I can still say: I have never cheated. I have never lied.
I have seen many who have cheated and lied, and, many including Game staff who have covered up and made excuses for the cheaters. This is especially true if the cheaters are among game staff and their circle of friends.
Many of them are still playing and/or running the game. Some are now “Elite” and others have recently been rewarded with staff positions for their compliance and ‘loyalty’ to the ‘Party Line’.
Watch out for them. They can not be trusted. Their innate fairness is compromised by their staff positions and/or relative to their proximity to Power within the game. They have too much to lose and so they are easy to intimidate.
IMPORTANT: For similar reasons of intimidation and because they have a lot to lose, many players who support my position are too intimidated to speak out in my defense. That is not healthy or fair.
I am banned without charges, without a BSEC hearing, without evidence and without opportunity to defend myself.
Yet this is what another player has to say about the newest Elite player, former Game Administrator and pivotal Game Staff member and co-conspirator in my ban Sage (SageEnterprises):
Former player, Rantz writes on his blog to/about Sage: “notice SageEnterprises - I still remember the day you asked BB (note: BB = Berlin Bear, another former player) and I to share passwords so we could use each other’s logins when our own artefacts were spent. Do you?”
http://rantz.phreacs.com.au/blogshares/2007/12/cheatypants.html
If this is true and even if it were the only example of possible cheating and/or unethical, dubious and questionable behavior by Sage it alone is a good reason why she should not have been given Elite status.
There are many more examples of Sage’s questionable actions which can be cited in great detail if and when necessary.
For example, Sage covered up the incredible ongoing abuse of Rare Place votes based on simple claims of Place in Profiles on dozens of fake and/or very dubious blogs. Then, recently and publicly in the forums Sage made a point of congratulating the player who was ‘finding’, adding, voting, opening and benefiting the most in these Rare Place industries. This despite the fact that Sage (and in fact all BSEC members and Admin) had been fully informed about these abuses. Some had the information for months yet did nothing to address or solve the problem. The problem has not been fully solved yet.
I will not recount in full detail the very dubious chips transactions Sage made once early in 2007 and again in May of 2007. I will point out that Sage used her position and power to ‘manage’ “Official” Game Corporations* which she controlled to her advantage as a player.
*(NOTE: Players, Caveat Emptor: It turns out that these “Official” corporations were not “Official” at all according to the Admin replies in the forums threads about this problem.)
Sage ‘bought’ nearly a half million chips at a price she set which was below the average market value and in much higher quantities than what was or ever has been available in the market. She then moved these chips to her personal ‘Player’ account. She personally benefited as a ‘player’ by using her ‘insider’ powers. No other player had her ’special’ advantage.
I do want to mention that I was encouraged by a number of players to bring these questionable chip transactions to light. I did, in the Forums, as suggested. At first many of them supported the questions and expressed their points of view that something dubious had occurred. Then, the usual suspects (AdamF, uninformed newer players who tend to try ingratiating themselves with TPTB) began their usual defenses of powerful inner circle Admin/game staff. Finally IslandDave showed up to shut down all discussion by ‘royal’ decree, shout everyone down and scare most everyone back into compliance with the ‘Party’ line. He also insulted and ran off a couple of long time players that day.
Sage not only did these questionable transactions, she was protected by IslandDave, AdamF, MrPilot and, Sage is rewarded with “Elite” status.
On the other hand I have never had special powers or insider support.
I have not cheated or suggested that anyone else cheat.
I raised these two issues (among on occasion raising other issues concerning fair play) in the forums when it became obvious that private discussions were not going result in any action.
Yet, Sage is Elite and I am banned from the game. Very Interesting.
Anyone who actually looks can clearly see that no evidence to support the ban against me has ever been provided.
There is no evidence. Ask for evidence, ask for proof. You will not receive any. All you will get is “we can’t tell you, but trust us, we have it” …
Why ? Because they do not have any proof. They do not have any evidence to support banning me.
I had nothing to do with whatever they claim to have on PnP (or MNO or other players). I doubt they have anything more than a record of legal play however aggressive it may be.
That said, I am not PnP. I am not guilty. My ban should be removed. Period.
In their action to ban us they lumped us and our alleged ’sins’ together with one set of fudged or faked numbers in a back room insider deal and dumped us both at once without warning or recourse for the benefit of a handful of insiders.
They cannot bring charges against me individually and apart from PnP because they cannot produce any evidence to show that I am at all guilty of any violations. Yet I am banned ?
Witch Hunt ? Lynch Mob ?
Yes.
AdamF claimed that there were threats of legal action for “harassment”. That is an excuse, not evidence. And: AdamF is incorrect: There were and still are no legal grounds for any type of harassment complaint.
I have played for 2 years and three months. All I have earned I earned legally and fairly and it has been wrongly taken away from me.
Is that a fair punishment ? For what ‘crime’ is it fair ?
This is what a few players have done. Their motives are to remove some they see or imagine as their major competition. They got enough support from among staff ‘volunteers’ and a few other players with personal agendas who threatened to quit.
This is all it took to force the issue and effect the bans. No evidence was required or produced because no evidence exists.
Sage, Sara, Honey, Matrixz and their ‘friends’ apparently have so little conscience that it pleases them take away EVERYTHING I gained in fair play and without cheating. They took it all from me by whining and complaining and obtaining a ban by fiat from the BOD/Admin.
They could not take it away legally and fairly in game play.
I was consistently staying ahead in Rares, in total Industries, in the amounts of Ideas I held, in Artifacts … and they could not abide my successes.
Sage and Sarabear are now effectively running the game and have ‘won’ it since their unethical forms of play are tolerated and rewarded by TPTB.
They forced the removal of 2 of 3 players they sought to remove by means of their false claims or lies and deceptions.
Some questions arising from this current situation are:
Were any rules broken ? Were warnings given ? Were charges brought ? Were opportunities for defense given ?
Additionally: Who benefitted ? Who would be so low as to feel good about stripping any other player(s) of legally and fairly earned assets requiring lots of time, hard work and effort ? Who could feel good about kicking them out of the game ? What types of people are they ?
I have worked hard for over 2 years to get what I earned FAIRLY in game play. Now, it is ALL GONE.
This means that ANYONE of the rest of you players can find themselves in this same situation if this group of players gets together and says they don’t like you - that they feel harassed, etc. There is great DANGER in that.
In the forums I have questioned many things, mainly things addressing inequities in game play. I have also offered suggestions for improving the game. That has always been a major goal. I have only always wanted a truly fair game for all players with a level playing field.
I may spout off in the forums but is that against the rules ? Is that a good reason to take away EVERYTHING I earned through fair play ? Since when ?
IslandDave says:
“These two players have lived for making the game unfun for too many people for far too long”.
I say that is not true, Dave is mistaken. I DID NOTHING IN THE GAME to make it “unfun” and they will not be able to produce evidence otherwise.
IslandDave says:
“While there may be no specific incident to point to to say ‘broken rules’, the body of evidence for harrassment (sic) from these two could fill volumes”.
I say he is right about this: I broke no rules.
I say that he is mistaken about this: I do not make harassment a practice. Proof, please ?
I could have been banned in the forums but broke no rules. So, no forums ban occurred until the wrongful permaban was imposed.
I could have been brought before the BSEC if they had any evidence to bring any charges. They do not have any evidence to bring to the BSEC.
I did nothing to be banned from the game. They made up excuses and used errors or lies, not facts, and had to link me to PnP to make this ban seem legitimate.
My ban is not legitimate at all. It is not fair at all.
They will not let me post. I assume it may be because they do not want to have to defend the indefensible decisions they have made.
I want to thank SubWolf for his support through our disagreements and wish him the best and a speedy recovery.
As I have always said: There is way too much behind the scenes crap going on in this game among a fairly small clique of game insiders. That is a sad fact and it is not good for the game or any of the players outside of that inner circle.
I want to thank those of you with a conscience for your support. There are many and you and I know who you are. I want you to know I fully understand your inability to speak up because you fear TPTB.
I know the game has so many problems that remain unsolved. It has a small core group of players who have conspired to strip away all my work and assets. Some have pressed to have me removed without any warning or evidence to support the ban. Then there are those who are compliant or intimidated.
These things are simply not fair.
I want to return to the game and I am still working towards that goal.
If I do not succeed in that then I will seek other remedies for the wrong I have suffered. You can count on that.
Best regards, AXA
PS: Due to the unfair, unwarranted, exceptional and unprecedented sell off of ALL of my Ideas Collection I am adding an edited version of the post that deals with this additional harm I have been dealt below. Thanks :
The Mistakes, Errors or Intentional Lies About Mass Sell Off Of AXA’s Ideas UPDATE PM 01.08.2008:
Some brave players tried to question the sell off. Thank you ! Of course their efforts and any opportunity for discussion were immediately shut down by Admin, Game Staff and their supporters.
First by Nexy who completely missed the point that the thread was not about the ban but about the sell off. Then by Sage and finally by AdamF who was mistaken or intentionally lying:
“AdamF: They’ve gone, end of story. If anyone has further issues with this, I suggest you contact Dave directly. It was the decision of the BoD. The airing of this in the forums is really starting to get boring, and my actions and those of others are not about stifling debate. The debate has been had. This, and the rest of the subsequent threads, are merely designed to admin-bait.
Oh look. Another locked thread.” he said, locking the thread on his way out …
Oh look, AdamF is either very misinformed, wrong and thoroughly incompetent or AdamF is a snarky, smarmy, arrogant, lying, sycophantic and power hungry bastard who has intentionally lied once again. I hope he is just misinformed, wrong and thoroughly incompetent. His history implies this may be the case. Unfortunately I fear he really is a snarky, smarmy, arrogant, lying, sycophantic and power hungry bastard who has intentionally lied once again as well as being misinformed, wrong and thoroughly incompetent.
This was NOT a BOD decision.
Jay (BOD) (and to my knowledge, Subwolf - BOD) did not know the ideas had been sold.
Jay said so in a private chat with me. Jay was going to let me pass all my assets to player Onyx or Subwolf. Then he (Jay) learned that the ideas were already gone. I have the chat logs to prove it and here is a very relevant excerpt from 11.26.2007:
“[13:39] –>| jay (jay@22A12016.2030049F.358434B7.IP) has joined #axa
[13:40]
[13:40]
[13:41]
[13:41]
[13:42]
[13:43]
So, it appears this sell off was done by others. The ‘others’ may include IslandDave who is but one of four members of the BOD (the otherBOD are/were C, Jay and Subwolf). The ‘others’ likely include AdamF and MrPilot, neither of whom is BOD, and both of whom worked with others in the conspiracy to permaban me without cause or evidence.
To my knowledge C, Jay and Subwolf were not privy to this decision or subsequent actions resulting in the sell off of all of my ideas.
Prior to my leaving for Thanksgiving and the sell off of all of my ideas the night I returned (Sunday, November 25th, 2007) Jay, Subwolf and I were involved in various discussions regarding the possible disposition of all of my assets.
Since Jay, Subwolf and I were discussing my assets before I left town and since he knew I was out of town for the holiday it would surprise me if Subwolf had any prior knowledge or role in the selling off all of my ideas before my return.
From the ongoing discussions I was under the impression that additional discussions and decisions regarding the disposition of my assets would continue after I returned from Thanksgiving. I still believe Subwolf is fair minded and would not have done that to me.
I may be wrong. The only indication I may be wrong is that he ‘banned’ me from an irc channel where I had never before been banned just as Jay and I were discussing the sell off the morning of Monday, November 26th, 2007.
Returning to posts related to the sell off in the forums:
Nexy was either mistaken or she was being disingenuous and intentionally obfuscating the issue of the sell off. Sage was just working her personal agenda. AdamF was either mistaken or he intentionally lied.
He has either been consistently mistaken or consistently intentionally lying since this whole mess unfolded. He has either been consistently mistaken or consistently intentionally lying since he first joined the game. He can not open his mouth without being either consistently mistaken or consistently intentionally lying. He was probably consistently mistaken or consistently intentionally lying while still in diapers, as soon as he could speak. A lifetime of incompetence or lies ! Yet, he is Admin and I am banned. I think I see a pattern.
By the way: later, after the sell off, Jay and I chatted. Jay offered to recreate/reconstitute all of my ideas holdings and pass them to Subwolf, an easy thing to do by means of a simple code/command. So when AdamF says “They’re gone” he is actually either mistaken or intentionally lying about that, too.
I turned that offer down as too little too late. I probably would have accepted it and let it all go if ALL of my ideas had not been sold off before discussions were completed, agreements reached and proper arrangements made.
After the sell off I wanted them passed to player Onyx instead.
Now I want ALL of them back in my own account and my ban removed so I can return to collecting more. .
And let’s not overlook these ‘gems’ from AdamF (who is trying out his version of IslandDave’s ‘Final Word’ tactic:
“my actions and those of others are not about stifling debate. The debate has been had. This, and the rest of the subsequent threads, are merely designed to admin-bait”
These statements, too, are even more mistakes or more intentional lies.
There has been no debate about the unprecedented and unwarranted sell off of all of my Ideas.
Incompetent fool ? Liar ? Hard to know for sure. Maybe both ? Whichever, He just can’t stop.
Returning to the IDEAS SELL OFF:
ALL of my ideas were sold off.
They claimed they just ran the regular ‘dead player sell script”. That is a mistake or a lie.
That script is supposed to run *after six months have passed* and that script only sells down to 10001 leaving 10001 and less ideas intact in the inactive account.
So, where are my ideas ? I earned them ALL legally and fairly in 2+ years of game play and I want them ALL restored to my account. I know it can be done, Jay said it could when he offered to reconstitute them all and pass them all to Subwolf.
This was posted in the forums about the sell off:
“FYI: The old player sell-off script only affects accounts on which there has been no login for at least 6 months.
EDIT: Except for this case, so I have learned.”
“EXCEPT FOR THIS CASE” ???
As I said, this action was Unprecedented and Unwarranted. It is EXCEPTIONAL. It is exceptionally WRONG.
ALL of my ideas were sold - down to zero. The best ideas collection in the history of the game.
That is just pure and brutal spite.
They could not beat me legally in the game or compete legally in ideas collecting so they resorted to this travesty.
Unprecedented, unwarranted, unfair ‘treatment’ - actually targeted harassment - of me.
What a nice way to treat someone who did not cheat in the game.
I wonder if I had followed this advice: “It’s usually a good idea for new players [noobs] to ingratiate themselves with the Index Managers and members of the BSEC” I would have been rewarded like so many others have ?
They had and still have no evidence to remove me. None. I am innocent.
They have no charges, just a simple brutal dislike of someone who played fair and beat them legally in fair play (on a dialup connection).
Now they have ‘erased’ all traces of my successes in the game.
I would have zero respect for anyone who does not question this punitive “sell off” except I know many of you are afraid to confront them.
And here is another set of mistaken assumptions and/or pack of LIES. This PM helped lay the groundwork for the rationale sarabear used to ‘game’ the baseless permaban:
A message from Aliens Co.
From DataLive MatrixZ
Block messages from this user
To XXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Date 06:58 26 Oct 2007
Many of you believe Untouchables to be some other corporation… and SWAT what is that?
It is a creation of AXA and PnP to build it and support it… so they can attack enemies without getting their “Alien” hands dirty…
so if your mindless and spineless you will be in good company with AXA and PnP and UT in SWAT.
Very sick weak little men and women with issues
your basic scared pissant fools!
done with this shit,
Matrixz
why do they have to run and hide at SWAT to do their dirt….
My ‘crimes’ ? I collected ideas. I was very successful. I spoke up against cheaters and injustices and I would not be intimidated.
I did not have anything to do with the creation of SWAT nor with any aggressive (but legal) play engaged in by SWAT.
Anyone who believed this paranoid rant or the other deceptions and lies are wrong.
Anyone who stands by under the guise of neutrality and lets this injustice stand are just as wrong.
I have no respect for those few whose perverse envy fueled this witch hunt, lynching and obliteration.
It makes it look as if the game truly is a collection of liars, cheaters, sycophants, sore losers, whiners, phonies, the uninformed, the weak, the intimidated and the compliant. Maybe it is.
Errors, mistakes, maybe lies, apathy and weakness enabled this abomination.
All of this because I was winning the game in several categories, because you could not intimidate me or beat me in legal game play or demonstrate any way in which I had cheated and because many of you are just compliant and/or intimidated.
They had to make a lot of mistakes and/or tell a lot of lies to get rid of me. I guess it was their only recourse.
Sad. For me, so far, and for all of you, too. These are the typical actions of the misinformed or of bullies and their followers.
Many thanks to all who can see the truth and all who have offered their support.
Here is AXA’s Statement from the Petition:
“I do not support this ban or any future bans like it and I would vote that way in the game poll if I could. To strip any player of game ranking and all assets earned fairly and legally in game play without any evidence and some public form of due process is absolutely wrong. To lie and conflate alleged offenses of multiple players together in order to remove them is wrong. To let a clique friendlier with BOD/Admin than most other players conspire with them to engineer this type of extreme injustice is wrong. To gloat after having participated in such a farce is sociopathic. - AXA”
Posted on January 6th, 2008 by AXA and filed under AXA, Blogshares, Ideas, ban | 1 Comment »
